The attempt was cleared by referee Paul Williams and his assistants, but New Zealand Rugby later asked World Rugby to clarify whether Sowakula`s actions were legal. It can be punished as a dangerous game, but the idea that it`s illegal unless you dive for the line is not true. Whatever the legitimacy of another contribution to May`s extraordinary final, England could contemplate a six-try win that would repair some of the damage done by Scotland`s horrific defeat a week earlier. “From the point of view of justice, a defender, if he does, can try to make a safe and legal attack against this player. As we have already mentioned, jumping to dodge an attack should be considered a dangerous game and punished accordingly, even if no contact is made. While May`s arrival has received much praise for her athleticism, there has been some debate over whether the attempt should have gone ahead, as it is illegal for players to avoid a duel by jumping. According to Test referee Centurion Owens, it was illegal because the Gloucester winger went up in the air to avoid Sperandio instead of using him as a means to achieve shutout. There has been some controversy as to whether it is legal for May to engage in the duel, but it is not really a crime in rugby laws. This has since led to an online rift between those who thought it was legal and those who thought he jumped into the duel, as well as a rabbit hole in terms of world rugby laws and regulations.
Referee Nigel Owens brought more clarity on Jonny May`s spectacular attempt against Italy this weekend – a result whose legality he questioned on Twitter. It is really a small problem in the laws. Once Jonny is in the air, the defender can legally do nothing but try to pass under him when he lands. An argument he addresses before diving on the line. But according to the current interpretation of the law, it will be considered legal He still has a long way to go to surpass England`s record scorer Rory Underwood at 49, but he showed great skill to land against Italy on that 32nd attempt. Hill produced a beautiful spinning pass to the winger, who then invaded the Italian defence to run under the posts without resistance. Speaking to World Rugby`s Whistle Watch, Owens explained why referee Mike Adamson and his official team decided to award the try. It is that in terms of goals scored and although the result was welcome for England, it was still not as convincing as expected. So it was a blow when their best time was ended by a reckless pass from Garbisi cleverly intercepted by Watson, who galloped 80 yards to score his second attempt. While it can certainly be argued that May`s attempt should not have stopped, there is no denying that it was an impressive finish from the prolific England winger. The Gloucester winger dived acrobatically to score an impressive try on the second day of the Six Nations at Twickenham last Saturday, and some fans wondered if May had jumped into the tackle. NZ Rugby also asked World Rugby to clarify whether England`s win over Italy in last year`s Six Nations should have been upheld.
Willis` jubilation on his second attempt was cruelly mitigated shortly after when his leg twisted during a clearance, causing a horrific left knee injury that pushed him off the field in the medical car. I`m a bit late, but if Johnny May is close to the line, then it`s a penalty for Italy because he jumps into a duel. OMI, it was a spectacular act to make an attempt. But laws are being pushed to their limits. pic.twitter.com/uG1oNdlKaJ Commenting on Hamilton`s tweet, former referee Nigel Owens said it was “perfect” and that May should have been punished by breaking the laws of jumping into or over a tackle. It`s been over three years since @benjaminryan wrote this about injuries in the collapse – and after Jack Willis` horrific injury, it`s just as relevant t.co/9DjyrTJrMp World Rugby`s rugby committee has now issued a clarification that this was a dangerous match and should have been a penalty against try scorer Sowakula. “You can practice it in training – you take out the crash mats and someone on the tackle bag will try to put you in touch – but it instinctively came to Jonny and then he`s the best.” Your place on Jim, you can`t jump to avoid such a tackle.
Recent Comments